"After all the progress I have made in these matters, I am still not happy with Algebra, because it provides neither the shortest ways nor the most beautiful constructions of Geometry. This is why when it comes to that, I think that we need another analysis which is properly geometric or linear, which expresses to us directly situm, in the same way as algebra expresses magnitudinem. And I think that I have the tools for that, and that we might represent figures and even engines and motion in character, in the same way as algebra represents numbers in magnitude." (Gottfried W Leibniz, [letter to Christiaan Huygens] 1679)
"I found the elements of a new characteristic, completely different from Algebra and which will have great advantages for the exact and natural mental representation, although without figures, of everything that depends on the imagination. Algebra is nothing but the characteristic of undetermined numbers or magnitudes. But it does not directly express the place, angles and motions, from which it follows that it is often difficult to reduce, in a computation, what is in a figure, and that it is even more difficult to find geometrical proofs and constructions which are enough practical even when the Algebraic calculus is all done." (Gottfried W Leibniz, [letter to Christiaan Huygens] 1679)
"I believe that we need another analysis properly geometric or linear, which treats PLACE directly the way that algebra treats MAGNITUDE." (Gottfried W Leibniz, 1670s)
"The branch of geometry that deals with magnitudes has been zealously studied throughout the past, but there is another branch that has been almost unknown up to now; Leibniz spoke of it first, calling it the ‘geometry of position’ (geometria situs). This branch of geometry deals with relations dependent on position; it does not take magnitudes into considerations, nor does it involve calculation with quantities. But as yet no satisfactory definition has been given of the problems that belong to this geometry of position or of the method to be used in solving them." (Leonhard Euler, 1735)
"The branch of geometry that deals with magnitudes has been zealously studied throughout the past, but there is another branch that has been almost unknown up to now; Leibniz spoke of it first, calling it the ‘geometry of position’ (geometria situs). This branch of geometry deals with relations dependent on position; it does not take magnitudes into considerations, nor does it involve calculation with quantities. But as yet no satisfactory definition has been given of the problems that belong to this geometry of position or of the method to be used in solving them." (Leonhard Euler, 1735)
"If in the case of a notion whose specialisations form a continuous manifoldness, one passes from a certain specialisation in a definite way to another, the specialisations passed over form a simply extended manifoldness, whose true character is that in it a continuous progress from a point is possible only on two sides, forward or backwards. If one now supposes that this manifoldness in its turn passes over into another entirely different, and again in a definite way, namely so that each point passes over into a definite point of the other, then all the specialisations so obtained form a doubly extended manifoldness. In a similar manner one obtains a triply extended manifoldness, if one imagines a doubly extended one passing over in a definite way to another entirely different; and it is easy to see how this construction may be continued. If one regards the variable object instead of the determinable notion of it, this construction may be described as a composition of a variability of n + 1 dimensions out of a variability of n dimensions and a variability of one dimension." (Bernhard Riemann, "On the hypotheses which lie at the foundation of geometry", 1854)
"The use of figures is, above all, then, for the purpose of making known certain relations between the objects that we study, and these relations are those which occupy the branch of geometry that we have called Analysis Situs [that is, topology], and which describes the relative situation of points and lines on surfaces, without consideration of their magnitude." (Henri Poincaré, "Analysis Situs", Journal de l'Ecole Polytechnique 1, 1895)
"[…] geometry is the art of reasoning well from badly drawn figures; however, these figures, if they are not to deceive us, must satisfy certain conditions; the proportions may be grossly altered, but the relative positions of the different parts must not be upset." (Henri Poincaré, 1895)
"And here is what makes this analysis situs interesting to us; it is that geometric intuition really intervenes there. When, in a theorem of metric geometry, one appeals to this intuition, it is because it is impossible to study the metric properties of a figure as abstractions of its qualitative properties, that is, of those which are the proper business of analysis situs. It has often been said that geometry is the art of reasoning correctly from badly drawn figures. This is not a capricious statement; it is a truth that merits reflection. But what is a badly drawn figure? It is what might be executed by the unskilled draftsman spoken of earlier; he alters the properties more or less grossly; his straight lines have disquieting zigzags; his circles show awkward bumps. But this does not matter; this will by no means bother the geometer; this will not prevent him from reasoning." (Henri Poincaré, "Dernières pensées", 1913)
"But it is a third geometry from which quantity is completely excluded and which is purely qualitative; this is analysis situs. In this discipline, two figures are equivalent whenever one can pass from one to the other by a continuous deformation; whatever else the law of this deformation may be, it must be continuous. Thus, a circle is equivalent to an ellipse or even to an arbitrary closed curve, but it is not equivalent to a straight-line segment since this segment is not closed. A sphere is equivalent to any convex surface; it is not equivalent to a torus since there is a hole in a torus and in a sphere there is not. Imagine an arbitrary design and a copy of this same design executed by an unskilled draftsman; the properties are altered, the straight lines drawn by an inexperienced hand have suffered unfortunate deviations and contain awkward bends. From the point of view of metric geometry, and even of projective geometry, the two figures are not equivalent; on the contrary, from the point of view of analysis situs, they are.” (Henri Poincaré, “Dernières pensées”, 1913)
"The use of figures is, above all, then, for the purpose of making known certain relations between the objects that we study, and these relations are those which occupy the branch of geometry that we have called Analysis Situs [that is, topology], and which describes the relative situation of points and lines on surfaces, without consideration of their magnitude." (Henri Poincaré, "Analysis Situs", Journal de l'Ecole Polytechnique 1, 1895)
"[…] geometry is the art of reasoning well from badly drawn figures; however, these figures, if they are not to deceive us, must satisfy certain conditions; the proportions may be grossly altered, but the relative positions of the different parts must not be upset." (Henri Poincaré, 1895)
"And here is what makes this analysis situs interesting to us; it is that geometric intuition really intervenes there. When, in a theorem of metric geometry, one appeals to this intuition, it is because it is impossible to study the metric properties of a figure as abstractions of its qualitative properties, that is, of those which are the proper business of analysis situs. It has often been said that geometry is the art of reasoning correctly from badly drawn figures. This is not a capricious statement; it is a truth that merits reflection. But what is a badly drawn figure? It is what might be executed by the unskilled draftsman spoken of earlier; he alters the properties more or less grossly; his straight lines have disquieting zigzags; his circles show awkward bumps. But this does not matter; this will by no means bother the geometer; this will not prevent him from reasoning." (Henri Poincaré, "Dernières pensées", 1913)
"But it is a third geometry from which quantity is completely excluded and which is purely qualitative; this is analysis situs. In this discipline, two figures are equivalent whenever one can pass from one to the other by a continuous deformation; whatever else the law of this deformation may be, it must be continuous. Thus, a circle is equivalent to an ellipse or even to an arbitrary closed curve, but it is not equivalent to a straight-line segment since this segment is not closed. A sphere is equivalent to any convex surface; it is not equivalent to a torus since there is a hole in a torus and in a sphere there is not. Imagine an arbitrary design and a copy of this same design executed by an unskilled draftsman; the properties are altered, the straight lines drawn by an inexperienced hand have suffered unfortunate deviations and contain awkward bends. From the point of view of metric geometry, and even of projective geometry, the two figures are not equivalent; on the contrary, from the point of view of analysis situs, they are.” (Henri Poincaré, “Dernières pensées”, 1913)
"That branch of mathematics which deals with the continuity properties of two- (and more) dimensional manifolds is called analysis situs or topology. […] Two manifolds must be regarded as equivalent in the topological sense if they can be mapped point for point in a reversibly neighborhood-true (topological) fashion on each other."
"Imagine any sort of model and a copy of it done by an awkward artist: the proportions are altered, lines drawn by a trembling hand are subject to excessive deviation and go off in unexpected directions. From the point of view of metric or even projective geometry these figures are not equivalent, but they appear as such from the point of view of geometry of position [that is, topology]." (Henri Poincaré, "Dernières pensées", 1920)
"Topology, or analysis situs, is a modern branch of geometry which […] does not bring in the notions of size or measure, but only that of continuity. It concerns itself, then, only with qualitative properties of figures. More precisely, one can define the aim of topology as follows. A property of a set is said to be topological if it can be expressed by means of the concept of continuity. A topological property of a set is called a topological invariant if it is preserved under all homeomorphisms. Topology is the study of topological properties and, especially, topological invariants of figures." (Maurice Frechet & Ky Fan, "Initiation to Combinatorial Topology", 1967)
"Imagine any sort of model and a copy of it done by an awkward artist: the proportions are altered, lines drawn by a trembling hand are subject to excessive deviation and go off in unexpected directions. From the point of view of metric or even projective geometry these figures are not equivalent, but they appear as such from the point of view of geometry of position [that is, topology]." (Henri Poincaré, "Dernières pensées", 1920)
"The young mathematical disciple 'topology' might be of some help in making psychology a real science." (Kurt Lewin, Principles of topological psychology, 1936)
"It is possible that analysis in the large may eventually
reduce to topology, but not until topology has been greatly broadened. It is
equally conceivable that the apparently less general situations which arise
with such frequency in problems in analysis in the large may form the canonical
cases about which the topology of the future can be built." (Marston Morse, "What
is Analysis in the Large?", The American Mathematical Monthly Vol. 49 (6), 1942)
"A definition is topological if it makes no use of mathematical elements other than those defined in terms of continuous deformations or transformations. Such deformations or transformations take the straightness out of planes and alter lengths and areas." (Marston Morse, "Equilibria in Nature: Stable and Unstable", Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society Vol. 93 (3), 1949)
"Topology begins where sets are implemented with some cohesive properties enabling one to define continuity." (Solomon Lefschetz, "Introduction to Topology", 1949)
"In topology we are concerned with geometrical facts that do not even involve the concepts of a straight line or plane but only the continuous connectiveness between points of a figure." (David Hilbert, "Geometry and Imagination", 1952)
"Topology begins where sets are implemented with some cohesive properties enabling one to define continuity." (Solomon Lefschetz, "Introduction to Topology", 1949)
"In topology we are concerned with geometrical facts that do not even involve the concepts of a straight line or plane but only the continuous connectiveness between points of a figure." (David Hilbert, "Geometry and Imagination", 1952)
"Topology, or analysis situs, is a modern branch of geometry which […] does not bring in the notions of size or measure, but only that of continuity. It concerns itself, then, only with qualitative properties of figures. More precisely, one can define the aim of topology as follows. A property of a set is said to be topological if it can be expressed by means of the concept of continuity. A topological property of a set is called a topological invariant if it is preserved under all homeomorphisms. Topology is the study of topological properties and, especially, topological invariants of figures." (Maurice Frechet & Ky Fan, "Initiation to Combinatorial Topology", 1967)
"In mathematics, logic, linguistics, and other abstract disciplines, the systems are not assigned to objects. They are defined by an enumeration of the variables, their admissible values, and their algebraic, topological, grammatical, and other properties which, in the given case, determine the relations between the variables under consideration." (George Klir, An approach to general systems theory, 1969)
"Topology provides the synergetic means of ascertaining the values of any system of experiences. Topology is the science of fundamental pattern and structural relationships of event constellations." (R Buckminster Fuller, "Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth", 1969)
"In geometry, topology is the study of properties of shapes that are independent of size or shape and are not changed by stretching, bending, knotting, or twisting." (M C Escher, 1971)
"Topology is not ‘designed to guide us’ in structure. It is this structure." (Jacques Lacan, "L’Étourdit", 1972)
"The connection of topology with physics is no passing interlude but rather represents a length affair." (Michael I Monastyrsky, "Riemann, Topology, and Physics", 1999)
"Topology is the property of something that doesn't change when you bend it or stretch it as long as you don't break anything." (Edward Witten, [interview] 2003)
"In geometry, topology is the study of properties of shapes that are independent of size or shape and are not changed by stretching, bending, knotting, or twisting." (M C Escher, 1971)
"Topology is not ‘designed to guide us’ in structure. It is this structure." (Jacques Lacan, "L’Étourdit", 1972)
"The philosophical emphasis here is: to solve a geometrical problem of a global nature, one first reduces it to a homotopy theory problem; this is in turn reduced to an algebraic problem and is solved as such. This path has historically been the most fruitful one in algebraic topology." (Brayton Gray, "Homotopy Theory", Pure and Applied Mathematics Vol 64, 1975)
"Because of its foundation in topology, catastrophe theory is qualitative, not quantitative. Just as geometry treated the properties of a triangle without regard to its size, so topology deals with properties that have no magnitude, for example, the property of a given point being inside or outside a closed curve or surface. This property is what topologists call 'invariant' -it does not change even when the curve is distorted. A topologist may work with seven-dimensional space, but he does not and cannot measure (in the ordinary sense) along any of those dimensions. The ability to classify and manipulate all types of form is achieved only by giving up concepts such as size, distance, and rate. So while catastrophe theory is well suited to describe and even to predict the shape of processes, its descriptions and predictions are not quantitative like those of theories built upon calculus. Instead, they are rather like maps without a scale: they tell us that there are mountains to the left, a river to the right, and a cliff somewhere ahead, but not how far away each is, or how large." (Alexander Woodcock & Monte Davis, "Catastrophe Theory", 1978)
"Topology has to do with those properties of a space which are left unchanged by the kind of transformation that we have called a topological equivalence or homeomorphism. But what sort of spaces interest us and what exactly do we mean by a 'space? The idea of a homeomorphism involves very strongly the notion of continuity [...]" (Mark A Armstrong, "Basic Topology", 1979)
"In every subject one looks for the topological and algebraic structures involved, since these structures form a unifying core for the most varied branches of mathematics." (K Weise and H Noack, "Aspects of Topology", 1986)"Linking topology and dynamical systems is the possibility of using a shape to help visualize the whole range of behaviors of a system. For a simple system, the shape might be some kind of curved surface; for a complicated system, a manifold of many dimensions. A single point on such a surface represents the state of a system at an instant frozen in time. As a system progresses through time, the point moves, tracing an orbit across this surface. Bending the shape a little corresponds to changing the system's parameters, making a fluid more visous or driving a pendulum a little harder. Shapes that look roughly the same give roughly the same kinds of behavior. If you can visualize the shape, you can understand the system." (James Gleick, "Chaos: Making a New Science", 1987)
"Topology deals with those properties of curves, surfaces, and more general aggregates of points that are not changed by continuous stretching, squeezing, or bending. To a topologist, a circle and a square are the same, because either one can easily be bent into the shape of the other. In three dimensions, a circle and a closed curve with an overhand knot in it are topologically different, because no amount of bending, squeezing, or stretching will remove the knot." (Edward N Lorenz, "The Essence of Chaos", 1993)
"Geometry and topology most often deal with geometrical figures, objects realized as a set of points in a Euclidean space (maybe of many dimensions). It is useful to view these objects not as rigid (solid) bodies, but as figures that admit continuous deformation preserving some qualitative properties of the object. Recall that the mapping of one object onto another is called continuous if it can be determined by means of continuous functions in a Cartesian coordinate system in space. The mapping of one figure onto another is called homeomorphism if it is continuous and one-to-one, i.e. establishes a one-to-one correspondence between points of both figures."
"Homeomorphism is one of the basic concepts in topology. Homeomorphism, along with the whole topology, is in a sense the basis of spatial perception. When we look at an object, we see, say, a telephone receiver or a ring-shaped roll and first of all pay attention to the geometrical shape (although we do not concentrate on it specially) - an oblong figure thickened at the ends or a round rim with a large hole in the middle. Even if we deliberately concentrate on the shape of the object and forget about its practical application, we do not yet 'see' the essence of the shape. The point is that oblongness, roundness, etc. are metric properties of the object. The topology of the form lies 'beyond them'."
"No other theory known to science [other than superstring theory] uses such powerful mathematics at such a fundamental level. […] because any unified field theory first must absorb the Riemannian geometry of Einstein’s theory and the Lie groups coming from quantum field theory. […] The new mathematics, which is responsible for the merger of these two theories, is topology, and it is responsible for accomplishing the seemingly impossible task of abolishing the infinities of a quantum theory of gravity." (Michio Kaku, "Hyperspace", 1995)
"No other theory known to science [other than superstring theory] uses such powerful mathematics at such a fundamental level. […] because any unified field theory first must absorb the Riemannian geometry of Einstein’s theory and the Lie groups coming from quantum field theory. […] The new mathematics, which is responsible for the merger of these two theories, is topology, and it is responsible for accomplishing the seemingly impossible task of abolishing the infinities of a quantum theory of gravity." (Michio Kaku, "Hyperspace", 1995)
"Since geometry is the mathematical idealization of space, a natural way to organize its study is by dimension. First we have points, objects of dimension O. Then come lines and curves, which are one-dimensional objects, followed by two-dimensional surfaces, and so on. A collection of such objects from a given dimension forms what mathematicians call a 'space'. And if there is some notion enabling us to say when two objects are 'nearby' in such a space, then it's called a topological space." (John L Casti, "Five Golden Rules", 1995)
"[...] there is no area of mathematics where thinking abstractly has paid more handsome dividends than in topology, the study of those properties of geometrical objects that remain unchanged when we deform or distort them in a continuous fashion without tearing, cutting, or breaking them." (John L Casti, "Five Golden Rules", 1995)
"Topology studies the properties of geometrical objects that remain unchanged under transformations called homeomorphisms and deformations." (Victor V Prasolov, "Intuitive Topology", 1995)"[...] if we consider a topological space instead of a plane, then the question of whether the coordinates axes in that space are curved or straight becomes meaningless. The way we choose coordinate systems is related to the way we observe the property of smoothness in a topological space." (Kenji Ueno & Toshikazu Sunada, "A Mathematical Gift, III: The Interplay Between Topology, Functions, Geometry, and Algebra", Mathematical World Vol. 23, 1996)
"The property of smoothness includes the property of continuity. The notion of a topological space was born from the development of abstract algebra as a universal notion for the property of continuity." (Kenji Ueno & Toshikazu Sunada, "A Mathematical Gift, III: The Interplay Between Topology, Functions, Geometry, and Algebra", Mathematical World Vol. 23, 1996)
"One of the basic tasks of topology is to learn to distinguish nonhomeomorphic figures. To this end one introduces the class of invariant quantities that do not change under homeomorphic transformations of a given figure. The study of the invariance of topological spaces is connected with the solution of a whole series of complex questions: Can one describe a class of invariants of a given manifold? Is there a set of integral invariants that fully characterizes the topological type of a manifold? and so forth."
"The connection of topology with physics is no passing interlude but rather represents a length affair." (Michael I Monastyrsky, "Riemann, Topology, and Physics", 1999)
"Topology makes it possible to explain the general structure of the set of solutions without even knowing their analytic expression." (Michael I Monastyrsky, "Riemann, Topology, and Physics", 1999)
"Topology studies those characteristics of figures which are preserved under a certain class of continuous transformations. Imagine two figures, a square and a circular disk, made of rubber. Deformations can convert the square into the disk, but without tearing the figure it is impossible to convert the disk by any deformation into an annulus. In topology, this intuitively obvious distinction is formalized."
"Topology is the property of something that doesn't change when you bend it or stretch it as long as you don't break anything." (Edward Witten, [interview] 2003)
"[…] topology, the study of continuous shape, a kind of generalized geometry where rigidity is replaced by elasticity. It's as if everything is made of rubber. Shapes can be continuously deformed, bent, or twisted, but not cut - that's never allowed. A square is topologically equivalent to a circle, because you can round off the corners. On the other hand, a circle is different from a figure eight, because there's no way to get rid of the crossing point without resorting to scissors. In that sense, topology is ideal for sorting shapes into broad classes, based on their pure connectivity."
"Topology is the mathematical study of properties of objects which are preserved through deformations, twistings, and stretchings but not through breaks or cuts." (David Robinson & David Goforth, "The Topology of the 2×2 Games: A New Periodic Table". 2005)
"Topology is the mathematical study of properties of objects which are preserved through deformations, twistings, and stretchings but not through breaks or cuts." (David Robinson & David Goforth, "The Topology of the 2×2 Games: A New Periodic Table". 2005)
"Topology is the study of geometric objects as they are transformed by continuous deformations. To a topologist the general shape of the objects is of more importance than distance, size, or angle."
"Poetry and code - and mathematics - make us read differently from other forms of writing. Written poetry makes the silent reader read three kinds of pattern at once; code moves the reader from a static to an active, interactive and looped domain; while algebraic topology allows us to read qualitative forms and their transformations." (Stephanie Strickland & Cynthia L Jaramillo, "Dovetailing Details Fly Apart - All over, again, in code, in poetry, in chreods", 2007)
"Poetry and code - and mathematics - make us read differently from other forms of writing. Written poetry makes the silent reader read three kinds of pattern at once; code moves the reader from a static to an active, interactive and looped domain; while algebraic topology allows us to read qualitative forms and their transformations." (Stephanie Strickland & Cynthia L Jaramillo, "Dovetailing Details Fly Apart - All over, again, in code, in poetry, in chreods", 2007)
"Topology makes it possible to explain the general structure of the set of solutions without even knowing their analytic expression." (Michael I Monastyrsky, "Riemann, Topology, and Physics" 2nd Ed., 2008)
"Topology is geometry without distance or angle. The geometrical objects of study, not rigid but rather made of rubber or elastic, are especially stretchy." (Stephen Huggett & David Jordan, "A Topological Aperitif", 2009)
"[…] topology is the study of those properties of geometric objects which remain unchanged under bi-uniform and bi-continuous transformations. Such transformations can be thought of as bending, stretching, twisting or compressing or any combination of these." (Lokenath Debnath, "The Legacy of Leonhard Euler - A Tricentennial Tribute", 2010)
"Topology is geometry without distance or angle. The geometrical objects of study, not rigid but rather made of rubber or elastic, are especially stretchy." (Stephen Huggett & David Jordan, "A Topological Aperitif", 2009)
"[…] topology is the study of those properties of geometric objects which remain unchanged under bi-uniform and bi-continuous transformations. Such transformations can be thought of as bending, stretching, twisting or compressing or any combination of these." (Lokenath Debnath, "The Legacy of Leonhard Euler - A Tricentennial Tribute", 2010)
"Topology, like other branches of pure mathematics such as group theory, is an axiomatic subject. We start with a set of axioms and we use these axioms to prove propositions and theorems. It is extremely important to develop your skill at writing proofs." (Sydney A Morris, "Topology without Tears", 2011)
"Topology, then, is really a mathematics of relationships, of unchangeable, or 'invariant', patterns." (Fritjof Capra, "The Systems View of Life: A Unifying Vision", 2014)
"At first, topology can seem like an unusually imprecise branch of mathematics. It’s the study of squishy play-dough shapes capable of bending, stretching and compressing without limit. But topologists do have some restrictions: They cannot create or destroy holes within shapes. […] While this might seem like a far cry from the rigors of algebra, a powerful idea called homology helps mathematicians connect these two worlds. […] homology infers an object’s holes from its boundaries, a more precise mathematical concept. To study the holes in an object, mathematicians only need information about its boundaries." (Kelsey Houston-Edwards, "How Mathematicians Use Homology to Make Sense of Topology", Quanta Magazine, 2021) [source]
"In geometry, shapes like circles and polyhedra are rigid objects; the tools of the trade are lengths, angles and areas. But in topology, shapes are flexible things, as if made from rubber. A topologist is free to stretch and twist a shape. Even cutting and gluing are allowed, as long as the cut is precisely reglued. A sphere and a cube are distinct geometric objects, but to a topologist, they’re indistinguishable." (David E Richeson, "Topology 101: The Hole Truth", 2021) [source]
No comments:
Post a Comment