29 March 2020

⏳About Mathematicians (1990-1999)

"A mathematician, then, will be defined in what follows as someone who has published the proof of at least one non-trivial theorem." (Jean Dieudonné, "Mathematics and Mathematicians", 1992)

"Engineers, always looking for optimal values for the measures of magnitudes which interest them, think of mathematicians as custodians of a fund of formulae, to be supplied to them on demand." (Jean Dieudonné, "Mathematics - The Music of Reason", 1992)

"Every mathematician worthy of the name has experienced the state of lucid exaltation in which one thought succeeds another as if miraculously. This feeling may last for hours at a time, even for days. Once you have experienced it, you are eager to repeat it but unable to do it at will, unless perhaps by dogged work." (André Weil, "The Apprenticeship of a Mathematician", 1992)

"In the flowering of a mathematical talent social environment has an important part to play." (Jean Dieudonné, "Mathematics - The Music of Reason", 1992)

"The life of a mathematician is dominated by an insatiable curiosity, a desire bordering on passion to solve the problems he is studying." (Jean Dieudonné, "Mathematics - The Music of Reason", 1992)

"[...] there is no criterion for appreciation which does not vary from one epoch to another and from one mathematician to another. [...] These divergences in taste recall the quarrels aroused by works of art, and it is a fact that mathematicians often discuss among themselves whether a theorem is more or less ‚beautiful‘. This never fails to surprise practitioners of other sciences: for them the sole criterion is the 'truth' of a theory or formula." (Jean Dieudonné, "Mathematics - The Music of Reason", 1992)

"To a mathematician, an object possesses symmetry if it retains its form after some transformation. A circle, for example, looks the same after any rotation; so a mathematician says that a circle is symmetric, even though a circle is not really a pattern in the conventional sense - something made up from separate, identical bits. Indeed the mathematician generalizes, saying that any object that retains its form when rotated - such as a cylinder, a cone, or a pot thrown on a potter's wheel - has circular symmetry." (Ian Stewart & Martin Golubitsky, "Fearful Symmetry: Is God a Geometer?", 1992)

"Virtually all mathematical theorems are assertions about the existence or nonexistence of certain entities. For example, theorems assert the existence of a solution to a differential equation, a root of a polynomial, or the nonexistence of an algorithm for the Halting Problem. A platonist is one who believes that these objects enjoy a real existence in some mystical realm beyond space and time. To such a person, a mathematician is like an explorer who discovers already existing things. On the other hand, a formalist is one who feels we construct these objects by our rules of logical inference, and that until we actually produce a chain of reasoning leading to one of these objects they have no meaningful existence, at all." (John L Casti, "Reality Rules: Picturing the world in mathematics" Vol. II, 1992)

"Mathematicians tells us that it is easy to invent mathematical theorems which are true, but that it is hard to find interesting ones. In analyzing music or writing its history, we meet the same difficulty, and it is compounded by another." (Charles Rosen, "The Frontiers of Meaning: Three Informal Lectures on Music", 1994)

"The bottom line for mathematicians is that the architecture has to be right. In all the mathematics that I did, the essential point was to find the right architecture. It's like building a bridge. Once the main lines of the structure are right, then the details miraculously fit. The problem is the overall design." (Freeman J Dyson, [interview] 1994)

"Ironically, mathematicians often infer all sorts of properties about objects which they only suspect, or hope, actually exist. If their suspicions turn out to be unfounded, then they seem to end up by knowing rather a lot about something which does not exist and which might seem, therefore, not to have any properties at all." (David Wells, "You Are a Mathematician: A wise and witty introduction to the joy of numbers", 1995)

"Mathematicians get a different kind of pleasure from the illumination of solving a problem, when what was once mysterious and obscure is made plain. Revealing the hidden connections in a situation is delightful - like reaching the top of a mountain after a hard climb, and seeing the landscape spread out before you. All of a sudden, everything is clear! If the result is extremely simple, so much the better . To start with confusing complexity and transform it into revealing simplicity is a marvellous reward for hard work. It really does give the mathematician a 'kick'!" (David Wells, "You Are a Mathematician: A wise and witty introduction to the joy of numbers", 1995)

"Mystery is found as much in mathematics as in detective stories. Indeed, the mathematician could well be described as a detective, brilliantly exploiting a few initial clues to solve the problem and reveal its innermost secrets. An especially mathematical mystery is that you can often search for some mathematical object, and actually know a lot about it, if it exists, only to discover that in fact it does not exist at all - you knew a lot about something which cannot be." (David Wells, "You Are a Mathematician: A wise and witty introduction to the joy of numbers", 1995)

"One of the greatest delights of mathematics is finding unity among apparent diversity; realizing that situations (or objects) that seemed to be quite different are actually basically the same. Spotting unexpected connections is not only a source of pleasure, it is an essential step in the development of mathematics. Without making connections, mathematics would quickly turn into a collection of separate topics, studied by mathematicians who had nothing to say to colleagues outside their own specialty." (David Wells, "You Are a Mathematician: A wise and witty introduction to the joy of numbers", 1995)

"The entrepreneur's instinct is to exploit the natural world. The engineer's instinct is to change it. The scientist's instinct is to try to understand it - to work out what's really going on. The mathematician's instinct is to structure that process of understanding by seeking generalities that cut across the obvious subdivisions." (Ian Stewart, "Nature's Numbers", 1995)

"Empirical evidence can never establish mathematical existence--nor can the mathematician's demand for existence be dismissed by the physicist as useless rigor. Only a mathematical existence proof can ensure that the mathematical description of a physical phenomenon is meaningful." (Richard Courant, "The Parsimonious Universe, Stefan Hildebrandt & Anthony Tromba", 1996)

"The whole thing that makes a mathematician's life worthwhile is that he gets the grudging admiration of three or four colleagues." (Donald E Knuth, [interview] 1996)

"To be an engineer, and build a marvelous machine, and to see the beauty of its operation is as valid an experience of beauty as a mathematician's absorption in a wondrous theorem. One is not ‘more’ beautiful than the other. To see a space shuttle standing on the launch pad, the vented gases escaping, and witness the thunderous blast-off as it climbs heavenward on a pillar of flame - this is beauty. Yet it is a prime example of applied mathematics.” (Calvin C Clawson, “Mathematical Mysteries”, 1996)

"Dynamics involves a crucial element: time. Symmetry is about shapes, which are things in space. How can symmetries apply to time? [...] We can even put both together, and look at patterns in space and time combined. Turning space into time is a typical mathematician's trick, a kind of 'technology transfer'. However, the 'technology' involved is conceptual technology - ideas - rather than gadgetry. No mathematician would ever waste a good idea by restricting it to just one incarnation. Many physically different systems possess an underlying mathematical identity: they obey rules which, in the abstract, are exactly the same - and must therefore lead to corresponding conclusions." (Ian Stewart, "The Magical Maze: Seeing the world through mathematical eyes", 1997)

“In many ways, the mathematical quest to understand infinity parallels mystical attempts to understand God. Both religions and mathematics attempt to express the relationships between humans, the universe, and infinity. Both have arcane symbols and rituals, and impenetrable language. Both exercise the deep recesses of our mind and stimulate our imagination. Mathematicians, like priests, seek ‘ideal’, immutable, nonmaterial truths and then often try to apply theses truth in the real world.” (Clifford A Pickover, "The Loom of God: Mathematical Tapestries at the Edge of Time", 1997)

“The most common instance of beauty in mathematics is a brilliant step in an otherwise undistinguished proof. […] A beautiful theorem may not be blessed with an equally beautiful proof; beautiful theorems with ugly proofs frequently occur. When a beautiful theorem is missing a beautiful proof, attempts are made by mathematicians to provide new proofs that will match the beauty of the theorem, with varying success. It is, however, impossible to find beautiful proofs of theorems that are not beautiful.” (Gian-Carlo Rota, “The Phenomenology of Mathematical Beauty”, 1997)

"What is a mathematician - someone who does mathematics? Not exactly. That's too easy an answer, and it creates too simple a maze - a circular loop of self-referential logic. No, a mathematician is more than just somebody who does mathematics. Think of it this way: what is a businessman? Someone who does business? Yes, but not just that. A businessman is someone who sees an opportunity for doing business where the rest of us see nothing: while we're complaining that there's no restaurant in the area, he's organising a telephone pizza delivery service. Similarly, a mathematician is someone who sees opportunities for doing mathematics that the rest of us miss." (Ian Stewart, "The Magical Maze: Seeing the world through mathematical eyes", 1997)

"Everybody knows that mathematics is about Miracles, only mathematicians have a name for them: Theorems." (Roger Howe, 1998)

"Rather mathematicians like to look for patterns, and the primes probably offer the ultimate challenge. When you look at a list of them stretching off to infinity, they look chaotic, like weeds growing through an expanse of grass representing all numbers. For centuries mathematicians have striven to find rhyme and reason amongst this jumble. Is there any music that we can hear in this random noise? Is there a fast way to spot that a particular number is prime? Once you have one prime, how much further must you count before you find the next one on the list? These are the sort of questions that have tantalized generations." (Marcus du Sautoy, "The Music of the Primes", 1998)

"A mathematician experiments, amasses information, makes a conjecture, finds out that it does not work, gets confused and then tries to recover. A good mathematician eventually does so – and proves a theorem." (Steven Krantz," Conformal Mappings", American Scientist, Sept.–Oct. 1999)

"Mathematicians, like the rest of us, cherish clever ideas; in particular they delight in an ingenious picture. But this appreciation does not overwhelm a prevailing skepticism. After all, a diagram is - at best - just a special case and so can't establish a general theorem. Even worse, it can be downright misleading. Though not universal, the prevailing attitude is that pictures are really no more than heuristic devices; they are psychologically suggestive and pedagogically important - but they prove nothing. I want to oppose this view and to make a case for pictures having a legitimate role to play as evidence and justification - a role well beyond the heuristic.  In short, pictures can prove theorems." (James R Brown, "Philosophy of Mathematics: An Introduction to the World of Proofs and Pictures", 1999)

"Physicists are more like avant-garde composers, willing to bend traditional rules and brush the edge of acceptability in the search for solutions. Mathematicians are more like classical composers, typically working within a much tighter framework, reluctant to go to the next step until all previous ones have been established with due rigor. Each approach has its advantages as well as drawbacks; each provides a unique outlet for creative discovery. Like modern and classical music, it’s not that one approach is right and the other wrong – the methods one chooses to use are largely a matter of taste and training." (Brian Greene, "The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory", 1999)

"The analogy with threading a maze runs deeper than games and puzzles. It illuminates the whole of mathematics. Indeed, one way to think about mathematics is as an exercise in threading an elaborate, infinitely large maze. A logical maze. A maze of ideas, whose pathways represent 'lines of thought' from one idea to another. A maze which, despite its apparent complexity, has a definite 'geography', to which mathematicians are unusually attuned." (Ian Stewart, "The Magical Maze: Seeing the World Through Mathematical Eyes", 1997)

“The spirit of mathematics and the essence of its beauty is remarkably fragile, because mathematics is about ideas and about thought. Mathematics takes place in the mind, and no two minds are the same. After many years of study and work, a mathematician may stumble on a vast and beautiful vista that unifies and simplifies many things that once appeared disparate and complicated. Mathematicians can share a beautiful mathematical vista with one another, but there is no camera that can easily capture an image of such a vista to convey it in full to people who have not trudged along many of the same trails.” (Silvio Levy, “The Eightfold Way: The Beauty of Klein’s Quartic Curve”, 1999)

⏳About Mathematicians (1980-1989)

“When a mathematician asks himself why some result should hold, the answer he seeks is some intuitive understanding. In fact, a rigorous proof means nothing to him if the result doesn’t make sense intuitively.” (Morris Kline, “Mathematics: The Loss of Certainty”, 1980)

"A mathematician’s work is mostly a tangle of guesswork, analogy, wishful thinking and frustration, and proof, far from being the core of discovery, is more often than not a way of making sure that our minds are not playing tricks." (Gian-Carlo Rota, 1981)

"For the great majority of mathematicians, mathematics is […] a whole world of invention and discovery - an art. The construction of a new theorem, the intuition of some new principle, or the creation of a new branch of mathematics is the triumph of the creative imagination of the mathematician, which can be compared to that of a poet, the painter and the sculptor." (George F J Temple, "100 Years of Mathematics: a Personal Viewpoint", 1981)

"In the initial stages of research, mathematicians do not seem to function like theorem-proving machines. Instead, they use some sort of mathematical intuition to ‘see’ the universe of mathematics and determine by a sort of empirical process what is true. This alone is not enough, of course. Once one has discovered a mathematical truth, one tries to find a proof for it." (Rudy Rucker, "Infinity and the Mind: The science and philosophy of the infinite", 1982)

"[…] a mathematician's ultimate concern is that his or her inventions be logical, not realistic. This is not to say, however, that mathematical inventions do not correspond to real things. They do, in most, and possibly all, cases. The coincidence between mathematical ideas and natural reality is so extensive and well documented, in fact, that it requires an explanation. Keep in mind that the coincidence is not the outcome of mathematicians trying to be realistic - quite to the contrary, their ideas are often very abstract and do not initially appear to have any correspondence to the real world. Typically, however, mathematical ideas are eventually successfully applied to describe real phenomena […]"(Michael Guillen, "Bridges to Infinity: The Human Side of Mathematics", 1983)

"Mathematicians might actually be looking at life with a most trenchant sense - one that perceives things the other five senses cannot." (Michael Guillen, "Bridges to Infinity: The Human Side of Mathematics", 1983) 

“[…] mathematics is not a science – it is not capable of proving or disproving the existence of real things. In fact, a mathematician’s ultimate concern is that his or her inventions be logical, not realistic.” (Michael Guillen, “Bridges to Infinity: The Human Side of Mathematics”, 1983)

"Mathematics has been called the science of the infinite. Indeed, the mathematician invents finite constructions by which questions are decided that by their very nature refer to the infinite. This is his glory." (Hermann Weyl, "Axiomatic versus constructive procedures in mathematics" , The Mathematical Intelligencer, 1985)

"Mathematics is not a deductive science - that's a cliché. When you try to prove a theorem, you don't just list the hypotheses, and then start to reason. What you do is trial and error, experimentation, guesswork. You want to find out what the facts are, and what you do is in that respect similar to what a laboratory technician does. Possibly philosophers would look on us mathematicians the same way as we look on the technicians, if they dared." (Paul R Halmos, "I Want to be a Mathematician: An Automathography", 1985)

"There are many things you can do with problems besides solving them. First you must define them, pose them. But then of course you can also refi ne them, depose them, or expose them or even dissolve them! A given problem may send you looking for analogies, and some of these may lead you astray, suggesting new and different problems, related or not to the original. Ends and means can get reversed. You had a goal, but the means you found didn’t lead to it, so you found a new goal they did lead to. It’s called play. Creative mathematicians play a lot; around any problem really interesting they develop a whole cluster of analogies, of playthings." (David Hawkins, "The Spirit of Play", Los Alamos Science, 1987

⏳About Mathematicians (1970-1979)

"Everything considered, mathematicians should have the courage of their most profound convictions and thus affirm that mathematical forms indeed have an existence that is independent of the mind considering them. […] Yet, at any given moment, mathematicians have only an incomplete and fragmentary view of this world of ideas." (René Thom, "Modern Mathematics: An Educational and Philosophical Error?", American Scientist Vol. 59, 1971)

"If some great mathematicians have known how to give lyrical expression to their enthusiasm for the beauty of their science, nobody has suggested examining it as if it were the object of an art - mathematical art -  and consequently the subject of a theory of aesthetics, the aesthetics of mathematics." (François Le Lionnais, "Great Currents of Mathematical Thought", 1971)

"Mathematicians are there to find the constraints and to eliminate those things that aren't constraints [...]" (Robert E Machol, Mathematicians are useful, 1971)

"Any mathematician endowed with a modicum of intellectual honesty will recognise then that in each of his proofs he is capable of giving a meaning to the symbols he uses." (René Thom, "Modern mathematics, does it exist?", 1972)

"For the mathematician, the physical way of thinking is merely the  starting point in a process of abstraction or idealization. Instead of being a dot on a piece of paper or a particle of dust suspended in space, a point becomes, in the mathematician's ideal way of thinking, a set of numbers or  coordinates. In applied mathematics we must go much further with this process because the physical problems under consideration are more complex. We first view a phenomenon in the physical way, of course, but we must then go through a process of idealization to arrive at a more abstract  representation of the phenomenon which will be amenable to mathematical analysis." (Peter Lancaster, "Mathematics: Models of the Real World", 1976)

"In many cases, mathematics is an escape from reality. The mathematician finds his own monastic niche and happiness in pursuits that are disconnected from external affairs. Some practice it as if using a drug. Chess sometimes plays a similar role. In their unhappiness over the events of this world, some immerse themselves in a kind of self-sufficiency in mathematics." (Stanislaw M Ulam, "Adventures of a Mathematician", 1976)

"You cannot read mathematics superficially; the inescapable abstraction always has an element of self-torture in it, and the one to whom this self-torture is joy is the mathematician." (Rózsa Péter, "Playing with Infinity: Mathematical Explorations and Excursions", 1976)

"Mathematicians do not agree among themselves whether mathematics is invented or discovered, whether such a thing as mathematical reality exists or is illusory." (Albert L Hammond, "Mathematics - Our invisible culture", 1978)

"Mathematicians have always been rather of a jealous nature, and undoubtedly jealousy was a family characteristic of the Bernoullis. There is some excuse for mathematicians, for their reputation stands for posterity largely not on what they did, but on what their contemporaries attributed to them." (Karl Pearson, "The History of Statistics in the 17th and 18th Century", 1978)

"On the face of it there should be no disagreement about mathematical proof. Everybody looks enviously at the alleged unanimity of mathematicians; but in fact there is a considerable amount of controversy in mathematics. Pure mathematicians disown the proofs of applied mathematicians, while logicians in turn disavow those of pure mathematicians. Logicists disdain the proofs of formalists and some intuitionists dismiss with contempt the proofs of logicists and formalists." (Imre Lakatos,"Mathematics, Science and Epistemology" Vol. 2, 1978)

"A proof is a construction that can be looked over, reviewed, verified by a rational agent. We often say that a proof must be perspicuous or capable of being checked by hand. It is an exhibition, a derivation of the conclusion, and it needs nothing outside itself to be convincing. The mathematician surveys the proof in its entirety and thereby comes to know the conclusion." (Thomas Tymoczko," The Four Color Problems", Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 76, 1979)

⏳About Mathematicians (1960-1969)

"As every mathematician knows, nothing is more fruitful than these obscure analogies, these indistinct reflections of one theory into another, these furtive caresses, these inexplicable disagreements; also nothing gives the researcher greater pleasure." (André Weil, "De la Métaphysique aux Mathématiques", 1960)

"In fact, the construction of mathematical models for various fragments of the real world, which is the most essential business of the applied mathematician, is nothing but an exercise in axiomatics." (Marshall Stone, cca 1960)

"Nothing in our experience suggests the introduction of [complex numbers]. Indeed, if a mathematician is asked to justify his interest in complex numbers, he will point, with some indignation, to the many beautiful theorems in the theory of equations, of power series, and of analytic functions in general, which owe their origin to the introduction of complex numbers. The mathematician is not willing to give up his interest in these most beautiful accomplishments of his genius." (Eugene P Wigner, “The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences”, Communications in Pure and Applied Mathematics 13 (1), 1960)

"Nothing is more fruitful - all mathematicians know it - than those obscure analogies, those disturbing reflections of one theory on another; those furtive caresses, those inexplicable discords; nothing also gives more pleasure to the researcher. The day comes when this illusion dissolves: the presentiment turns into certainty; the yoked theories reveal their common source before disappearing. As the Gita teaches, one achieves knowledge and indifference at the same time. Metaphysics has become Mathematics, ready to form the material of some treatise whose cold beauty has lost the power to move us." (André Weil, "De la métaphysique aux mathématiques", 1960)

"It seems to be one of the fundamental features of nature that fundamental physical laws are described in terms of a mathematical theory of great beauty and power, needing quite a high standard of mathematics for one to understand it. You may wonder: Why is nature constructed along these lines? One can only answer that our present knowledge seems to show that nature is so constructed. We simply have to accept it. One could perhaps describe the situation by saying that God is a mathematician of a very high order, and He used very advanced mathematics in constructing the universe. Our feeble attempts at mathematics enable us to understand a bit of the universe, and as we proceed to develop higher and higher mathematics we can hope to understand the universe better." (Paul Dirac, "The Evolution of the Physicist's Picture of Nature", 1963)

"Mathematics is a creation of the mind. To begin with, there is a collection of things, which exist only in the mind, assumed to be distinguishable from one another; and there is a collection of statements about these things, which are taken for granted. Starting with the assumed statements concerning these invented or imagined things, the mathematician discovers other statements, called theorems, and proves them as necessary consequences. This, in brief, is the pattern of mathematics. The mathematician is an artist whose medium is the mind and whose creations are ideas." (Hubert S Wall," Creative Mathematics", 1963)

"A theory with mathematical beauty is more likely to be correct than an ugly one that fits some experimental data. God is a mathematician of a very high order, and He used very advanced mathematics in constructing the universe." (Paul Dirac, Scientific American, 1963)

"[…] it is more important to have beauty in one's equations that to have them fit experiment. […] It seems that if one is working from the point of view of getting beauty in one's equations, and if one has really a sound insight, one is on a sure line of progress." (Paul Dirac, Scientific American, 1963)  

"It becomes the urgent duty of mathematicians, therefore, to meditate about the essence of mathematics, its motivations and goals and the ideas that must bind divergent interests together." (Richard Courant, "Mathematics in the Modern World", Scientific American Vol. 211, 1964)

"When the problems in physics become difficult we may often look to the mathematician who may already have studied such things and have prepared a line of reasoning for us to follow. On the other hand they may not have, in which case we have to invent our own line of reasoning, which we then pass back to the mathematician." (Richard Feynman,"The Character of Physical Law", 1965)

🅼Marvin Minsky - Collected Quotes

"Computer languages of the future will be more concerned with goals and less with procedures specified by the programmer." (Marvin Minsky, "Form and Content in Computer Science", [Turing Award lecture] 1969)

"A memory should induce a state through which we see current reality as an instance of the remembered event - or equivalently, see the past as an instance of the present. […] the system can perform a computation analogous to one from the memorable past, but sensitive to present goals and circumstances." (Marvin Minsky, "K-Linesː A Theory of Memory", 1980) 

"Since we have no systematic way to avoid all the inconsistencies of commonsense logic, each person must find his own way by building a private collection of 'cognitive censors' to suppress the kinds of mistakes he has discovered in the past." (Marvin Minsky, "Jokes and their Relation to the Cognitive Unconscious", 1980) 

"When you, ‘get an idea’, or ‘solve a problem’, or have a ‘memorable experience’, you create what we shall call a K-line. This K-line gets connected to those ‘mental agencies’ that were actively involved in the memorable event. When that K-line is later ‘activated’, it reactivates some of those mental agencies, creating a ‘partial mental state’ resembling the original." (Marvin Minsky, "K-Linesː A Theory of Memory", 1980) 

"If explaining minds seems harder than explaining songs, we should remember that sometimes enlarging problems makes them simpler! The theory of the roots of equations seemed hard for centuries within its little world of real numbers, but it suddenly seemed simple once Gauss exposed the larger world of so-called complex numbers. Similarly, music should make more sense once seen through listeners' minds." (Marvin Minsky, "Music, Mind, and Meaning", 1981)

"The way the mathematics game is played, most variations lie outside the rules, while music can insist on perfect canon or tolerate a casual accompaniment." (Marvin Minsky, "Music, Mind, and Meaning", 1981)

"Theorems often tell us complex truths about the simple things, but only rarely tell us simple truths about the complex ones. To believe otherwise is wishful thinking or ‘mathematics envy’." (Marvin Minsky, "Music, Mind, and Meaning", 1981)

"What is the difference between merely knowing (or remembering, or memorizing) and understanding? […] A thing or idea seems meaningful only when we have several different ways to represent it - different perspectives and different associations […]. Then we can turn it around in our minds, so to speak: however it seems at the moment, we can see it another way and we never come to a full stop. In other words, we can 'think' about it. If there were only one way to represent this thing or idea, we would not call this representation thinking." (Marvin Minsky, "Music, Mind, and Meaning", 1981)

"The hardest problems we have to face do not come from philosophical questions about whether brains are machines or not. There is not the slightest reason to doubt that brains are anything other than machines with enormous numbers of parts that work in perfect accord with physical laws. As far as anyone can tell, our minds are merely complex processes. The serious problems come from our having had so little experience with machines of such complexity that we are not yet prepared to think effectively about them." (Marvin Minsky, 1986)

"For generations, scientists and philosophers have tried to explain ordinary reasoning in terms of logical principles - with virtually no success. I suspect this enterprise failed because it was looking in the wrong direction: common sense works so well not because it is an approximation of logic; logic is only a small part of our great accumulation of different, useful ways to chain things together." (Marvin Minsky, "The Society of Mind", 1987) 

"General fiction is pretty much about ways that people get into problems and screw their lives up. Science fiction is about everything else." (Marvin Minsky, "The Society of Mind", 1987)

"Unless we can explain the mind in terms of things that have no thoughts or feelings of their own, we'll only have gone around in a circle." (Marvin Minsky, "The Society of Mind", 1987) 

"The idea that the world exists is like adding an extra term to an equation that doesn’t belong there." (Marvin Minsky, "The Emotion Universe", [essay] 2002)

"Every system that we build will surprise us with new kinds of flaws until those machines become clever enough to conceal their faults from us." (Marvin Minsky, "The Emotion Machine: Commonsense Thinking, Artificial Intelligence, and the Future of the Human Mind", 2006)

"It makes no sense to seek a single best way to represent knowledge - because each particular form of expression also brings its particular limitations. For example, logic-based systems are very precise, but they make it hard to do reasoning with analogies. Similarly, statistical systems are useful for making predictions, but do not serve well to represent the reasons why those predictions are sometimes correct." (Marvin Minsky, "The Emotion Machine: Commonsense Thinking, Artificial Intelligence, and the Future of the Human Mind", 2006)

⏳About Mathematicians (1950-1959)

“Mathematicians create by acts of insight and intuition. Logic then sanctions the conquests of intuition. It is the hygiene that mathematics practice to keep its ideas healthy and strong. Moreover, the whole structure rests fundamentally on uncertain ground, the intuitions of man.” (Morris Kline, “Mathematics in Western Culture”, 1953)

"Mathematicians do not know what they are talking about because pure mathematics is not concerned with physical meaning. Mathematicians never know whether what they are saying is true because, as pure mathematicians, they make no effort to ascertain whether their theorems are true assertions about the physical world." (Morris Kline, “Mathematics in Western Culture”, 1953)

"The advantage is that mathematics is a field in which one’s blunders tend to show very clearly and can be corrected or erased with a stroke of the pencil. It is a field which has often been compared with chess, but differs from the latter in that it is only one’s best moments that count and not one’s worst. A single inattention may lose a chess game, whereas a single successful approach to a problem, among many which have been relegated to the wastebasket, will make a mathematician’s reputation.” (Norbert Wiener, “Ex-Prodigy: My Childhood and Youth”, 1953)

"Mathematics, like music and poetry, is a creation of the mind; [...] the primary task of the mathematician, like that of any other artist, is to extend man's mental horizon by representation and interpretation." (Graham Sutton, "Mathematics in Action", 1954) 

"Rigor is to the mathematician what morality is to man. It does not consist in proving everything, but in maintaining a sharp distinction between what is assumed and what is proved, and in endeavoring to assume as little as possible at every stage." (André Weil, Mathematical Teaching in Universities", The American Mathematical Monthly Vol. 61 (1), 1954)

"The result of the mathematician's creative work is demonstrative reasoning, a proof; but the proof is discovered by plausible reasoning, by guessing. If the learning of mathematics reflects to any degree the invention of mathematics, it must have a place for guessing, for plausible inference." (George Pólya,"Induction and Analogy in Mathematics", 1954)

"You have to guess the mathematical theorem before you prove it: you have to guess the idea of the proof before you carry through the details. You have to combine observations and follow analogies: you have to try and try again. The result of the mathematician’s creative work is demonstrative reasoning, a proof; but the proof is discovered by plausible reasoning, by guessing" (George Polya, "Mathematics and plausible reasoning" Vol. 1, 1954)

“The creative act owes little to logic or reason. In their accounts of the circumstances under which big ideas occurred to them, mathematicians have often mentioned that the inspiration had no relation to the work they happened to be doing. Sometimes it came while they were traveling, shaving or thinking about other matters. The creative process cannot be summoned at will or even cajoled by sacrificial offering. Indeed, it seems to occur most readily when the mind is relaxed and the imagination roaming freely.” (Morris Kline, Scientific American, 1955)

"The mathematicians know a great deal about very little and the physicists very little about a great deal." (Stanislaw Ulam, "On the Ergodic Behavior of Dynamical Systems", 1955)

"A creative mathematician is the intersection of several unlikely events, For the most part we are ignorant of the nature of these events and of their probabilities. Some of them are at present quite beyond our controls. An example is the probability of a genetic composition necessary for intensive and highly abstract thinking. Others are clearly subject to our influence. For example, the probability of an early acquaintance with living mathematics and with the joy of mathematical achievement is determined by educational practices." (Kenneth O May "Undergraduate Research in Mathematics",  The American Mathematical Monthly 65, 1958) 

"Mathematical examination problems are usually considered unfair if insoluble or improperly described: whereas the mathematical problems of real life are almost invariably insoluble and badly stated, at least in the first balance. In real life, the mathematician's main task is to formulate problems by building an abstract mathematical model consisting of equations, which will be simple enough to solve without being so crude that they fail to mirror reality. Solving equations is a minor technical matter compared with this fascinating and sophisticated craft of model-building, which calls for both clear, keen common-sense and the highest qualities of artistic and creative imagination." (John Hammersley & Mina Rees, "Mathematics in the Market Place", The American Mathematical Monthly 65, 1958) 

“Mathematics are the result of mysterious powers which no one understands, and which the unconscious recognition of beauty must play an important part. Out of an infinity of designs a mathematician chooses one pattern for beauty's sake and pulls it down to earth.” (Marston Morse, 1959) 

"No one will get very far or become a real mathematician without certain indispensable qualities. He must have hope, faith, and curiosity, and prime necessity is curiosity." (Louis J Mordell, "Reflections of a Mathematician", 1959)

"The mathematician, the statistician, and the philosopher do different things with a theory of probability. The mathematician develops its formal consequences, the statistician applies the work of the mathematician and the philosopher describes in general terms what this application consists in. The mathematician develops symbolic tools without worrying overmuch what the tools are for; the statistician uses them; the philosopher talks about them. Each does his job better if he knows something about the work of the other two." (Irvin J Good, “Kinds of Probability”, Science Vol. 129, 1959)

⏳About Mathematicians (1940-1949)

"A mathematician, like a painter or a poet, is a maker of patterns. [...]. The mathematician's patterns, like the painter's or the poet's, must be beautiful; the ideas, like the colours or the words, must fit together in a harmonious way. Beauty is the first test: there is no permanent place in the world for ugly mathematics." (Godfrey H Hardy, “A Mathematician's Apology”, 1940)

"At the present time it is of course quite customary for physicists to trespass on chemical ground, for mathematicians to do excellent work in physics, and for physicists to develop new mathematical procedures […] Trespassing is one of the most successful techniques in science." (Wolfgang Köhler, "Dynamics in Psychology", 1940)

"It is a far finer gambit than any chess gambit: a chess player may offer the sacrifice of a pawn or even a piece, but a mathematician offers the game." (Godfrey H Hardy, "A Mathematician's Apology", 1940)

"It is a melancholic experience for a professional mathematician to find himself writing about mathematics. The function of a mathematician is to do something, to prove new theorems, to add to mathematics, and not to talk about what he or other mathematicians have done [...] there is no scorn more profound, or on the whole more justifiable, than that of the men who make for the men who explain. Exposition, criticism, appreciation, is work for second-rate minds.“  (Godfrey H Hardy, "A Mathematician's Apology“, 1940)

“Mathematics is not a contemplative but a creative subject; no one can draw much consolation from it when he has lost the power or the desire to create; and that is apt to happen to a mathematician rather soon.” (Godfrey H Hardy, "A Mathematician's Apology“, 1940)

“The mathematician is still regarded as the hermit who knows little of the ways of life outside his cell, who spends his time compounding incredible and incomprehensible theorems in a strange, clipped, unintelligible jargon.” (James R Newman, “Mathematics and the Imagination”, 1940)

"[…] there is probably less difference between the positions of a mathematician and of a physicist than is generally supposed, [...] the mathematician is in much more direct contact with reality. This may seem a paradox, since it is the physicist who deals with the subject-matter usually described as 'real', but [...] [a physicist] is trying to correlate the incoherent body of crude fact confronting him with some definite and orderly scheme of abstract relations, the kind of scheme he can borrow only from mathematics." (Godfrey H Hardy, "A Mathematician's Apology", 1940)

"We now come to a decisive step of mathematical abstraction: we forget about what the symbols stand for […] The mathematician] need not be idle; there are many operations which he may carry out with these symbols, without ever having to look at the things they stand for." (Hermann Weyl, "The Mathematical Way of Thinking", 1940)

"A serious threat to the very life of science is implied in the assertion that mathematics is nothing but a system of conclusions drawn from definitions and postulates that must be consistent but otherwise may be created by the free will of the mathematician. If this description were accurate, mathematics could not attract any intelligent person. It would be a game with definitions, rules and syllogisms, without motivation or goal." (Richard Courant & Herbert Robbins, "What Is Mathematics?", 1941)

"Mathematicians deal with possible worlds, with an infinite number of logically consistent systems. Observers explore the one particular world we inhabit. Between the two stands the theorist. He studies possible worlds but only those which are compatible with the information furnished by observers. In other words, theory attempts to segregate the minimum number of possible worlds which must include the actual world we inhabit. Then the observer, with new factual information, attempts to reduce the list further. And so it goes, observation and theory advancing together toward the common goal of science, knowledge of the structure and observation of the universe." (Edwin P Hubble, "The Problem of the Expanding Universe", 1941)

"Mathematicians themselves set up standards of generality and elegance in their exposition which are a bar to understand." (Kenneth E Boulding, "Economic Analysis", 1941)

"It is to be hoped that in the future more and more theoretical physicists will command a deep knowledge of mathematical principles; and also that mathematicians will no longer limit themselves so exclusively to the aesthetic development of mathematical abstractions." (George D Birkhoff, "Mathematical Nature of Physical Theories" American Scientific Vol. 31 (4), 1943)

"A mathematician is not a man who can readily manipulate figures; often he cannot. He is not even a man who can readily perform the transformations of equations by the use of calculus. He is primarily an individual who is skilled in the use of symbolic logic on a high plane, and especially he is a man of intuitive judgment in the choice of the manipulative processes he employs." (Vannevar Bush, "As We May Think", 1945)

"In various ways, methods of approaching the mathematician's ideal were sought, and the resulting suggestions were the source of much that was mistaken in metaphysics and theory of knowledge.” (Bertrand Russell, “A History of Western Philosophy”, 1945)

"One of the difficulties which a mathematician has in describing his work to non-mathematicians is that the present day language of mathematics has become so esoteric that a well educated layman, or even a group of scientists, can comprehend essentially nothing of the discourse which mathematicians hold with each other, or of the accounts of their latest researches which are published in their professional journals." (Angus E Taylor, "Some Aspects of Mathematical Research", American Scientist , Vol. 35, No. 2, 1947)

"[…] mathematicians progress only by doubt, through humble and constant attempts to impinge on the immense domain of the unknown." (Leopold Infeld, "Whom the Gods Love: The Story of Évariste Galois", 1948)

⏳About Mathematicians (1910-1919)

"Many mathematicians continue to reject the axiom of choice. The growing realization that there are questions in mathematics that cannot be decided without this principle is likely to result in the gradual disappearance of the resistance to it." (Ernst Steinitz, "Algebraische Theorie der Körper" ["Algebraic theory of fields"], 1910) 

"Mathematicians attach great importance to the elegance of their methods and their results. This is not pure dilettantism. What is it indeed that gives us the feeling of elegance in a solution, in a demonstration? It is the harmony of the diverse parts, their symmetry, their happy balance; in a word it is all that introduces order, all that gives unity, that permits us to see clearly and to comprehend at once both the ensemble and the details." (Henri Poincaré, “The Future of Mathematics”, Monist Vol. 20, 1910)

"The critical mathematician has abandoned the search for truth. He no longer flatters himself that his propositions are or can be known to him or to any other human being to be true; and he contents himself with aiming at the correct, or the consistent. The distinction is not annulled nor even blurred by the reflection that consistency contains immanently a kind of truth. He is not absolutely certain, but he believes profoundly that it is possible to find various sets of a few propositions each such that the propositions of each set are compatible, that the propositions of each such set imply other propositions, and that the latter can be deduced from the former with certainty. That is to say, he believes that there are systems of coherent or consistent propositions, and he regards it his business to discover such systems. Any such system is a branch of mathematics." (Cassius J Keyser, Science, New Series, Vol. 35 (904), 1912)

"It may be surprising to see emotional sensibility invoked apropos of mathematical demonstrations which, it would seem, can interest only the intellect. This would be to forget the feeling of mathematical beauty, of the harmony of numbers and forms, of geometric elegance. This is a true esthetic feeling that all real mathematicians know, and surely it belongs to emotional sensibility." (Henri Poincaré, 1913)

"It would only be possible to imagine life or beauty as being strictly mathematical if we ourselves were such infinitely capable mathematicians as to be able to formulate their characteristics in mathematics so extremely complex that we have never yet invented them." (Theodore A Cook, "The Curves of Life", 1914)

“[…] the mathematician is always walking upon the brink of a precipice, for, no matter how many theorems he deduces, he cannot tell that some contradiction will not await him in the infinity of consequences.” (Richard A Arms, “The Notion of Number and the Notion of Class”, 1917)

"The concept of an independent system is a pure creation of the imagination. For no material system is or can ever be perfectly isolated from the rest of the world. Nevertheless it completes the mathematician’s ‘blank form of a universe’ without which his investigations are impossible. It enables him to introduce into his geometrical space, not only masses and configurations, but also physical structure and chemical composition." (Lawrence J Henderson, "The Order of Nature: An Essay", 1917)

⏳About Mathematicians (1900-1909)

"The mathematician, carried along on his flood of symbols, dealing apparently with purely formal truths, may still reach results of endless importance for our description of the physical universe." (Karl Pearson, “The Grammar of Science”, 1900)

"Mathematicians do not study objects, but the relations between objects; to them it is a matter of indifference if these objects are replaced by others, provided that the relations do not change. Matter does not engage their attention, they are interested in form alone." (Henri Poincaré, "Science and Hypothesis", 1901)

"Mathematicians therefore proceed 'by construction', they 'construct' more complicated combinations. When they analyse these combinations, these aggregates, so to speak, into their primitive elements, they see the relations of the elements and deduce the relations of the aggregates themselves. The process is purely analytical, but it is not a passing from the general to the particular, for the aggregates obviously cannot be regarded as more particular than their elements." (Henri Poincaré, "Science and Hypothesis", 1902)

"The apodictic quality of mathematical thought, the certainty and correctness of its conclusions, are due, not to a special mode of ratiocination, but to the character of the concepts with which it deals. What is that distinctive characteristic? I answer: precision, sharpness, completeness of definition. But how comes your mathematician by such completeness? There is no mysterious trick involved; some ideas admit of such precision, others do not; and the mathematician is one who deals with those that do." (Cassius J Keyser, "The Universe and Beyond", Hibbert Journal Vol. 3, 1904–1905)

"To think the thinkable - that is the mathematician's aim." (Cassius J Keyser, "The Universe and Beyond", Hibbert Journal Vol. 3, 1904-1905)

“A mathematical theorem and its demonstration are prose. But if the mathematician is overwhelmed with the grandeur and wondrous harmony of geometrical forms, of the importance and universal application of mathematical maxims, or, of the mysterious simplicity of its manifold laws which are so self-evident and plain and at the same time so complicated and profound, he is touched by the poetry of his science; and if he but understands how to give expression to his feelings, the mathematician turns poet, drawing inspiration from the most abstract domain of scientific thought.” (Paul Carus, “Friedrich Schiller”, 1905)

"The chief end of mathematical instruction is to develop certain powers of the mind, and among these the intuition is not the least precious. By it the mathematical world comes in contact with the real world, and even if pure mathematics could do without it, it would always be necessary to turn to it to bridge the gulf between symbol and reality. The practician will always need it, and for one mathematician there are a hundred practicians. However, for the mathematician himself the power is necessary, for while we demonstrate by logic, we create by intuition; and we have more to do than to criticize others’ theorems, we must invent new ones, this art, intuition teaches us." (Henri Poincaré, "The Value of Science", 1905)

"The great mathematician, like the great poet or great naturalist or great administrator, is born." (Cassius J Keyser, "Lectures on Science, Philosophy and Art", 1908)

⏳About Mathematicians (1875-1899)

“It is the constant aim of the mathematician to reduce all his expressions to their lowest terms, to retrench every superfluous word and phrase, and to condense the Maximum of meaning into the Minimum of language.” (James J Sylvester, 1877)

"The union of the mathematician with the poet, fervor with measure, passion with correctness, this surely is the ideal." (William James, "Clifford's Lectures and Essays", 1879)

"[...] it is true that a mathematician who is not somewhat of a poet, will never be a perfect mathematician." (Karl Weierstrass, [Letter to Sofia Kovalevskaya] 1883)

"A scientist worthy of the name, above all a mathematician, experiences in his work the same impression as an artist; his pleasure is as great and of the same nature.... we work not only to obtain the positive results which, according to the profane, constitute our one and only affection, as to experience this esthetic emotion and to convey it to others who are capable of experiencing it." (Henri Poincaré, "Notice sur Halphen", Journal de l'École Polytechnique, 1890)

"There is probably no other science which presents such different appearances to one who cultivates it and one who does not, as mathematics. To [the noncultivator] it is ancient, venerable, and complete; a body of dry, irrefutable, unambiguous reasoning. To the mathematician, on the other hand, his science is yet in the purple bloom of vigorous youth, everywhere stretching out after the 'attainable but unattained', and full of the excitement of nascent thoughts; its logic is beset with ambiguities, and its analytic processes, like Bunyan's road, have a quagmire on one side and a deep ditch on the other, and branch off into innumerable by-paths that end in a wilderness." (Charles H Chapman, Bulletin of the New York Mathematical Society 2, 1892)
 
“With our notion of the essence of intuition, an intuitive treatment of figurative representations will tend to yield a certain general guide on which mathematical laws apply and how their general proof may be structured. However, true proof will only be obtained if the given figures are replaced with figures generated by laws based on the axioms and these are then taken to carry through the general train of thought in an explicit case. Dealing with sensate objects gives the mathematician an impetus and an idea of the problems to be tackled, but it does not pre-empt the mathematical process itself. (Felix Klein, “Nicht-Euklidische Geometrie I: Vorlesung gehalten während des Wintersemesters 1889–90”, 1892)
 
"The contemplation of the various steps by which mankind has come into possession of the vast stock of mathematical knowledge can hardly fail to interest the mathematician. He takes pride in the fact that his science, more than any other, is an exact science, and that hardly anything ever done in mathematics has proved to be useless." (Florian Cajori, "A History of Mathematics", 1893)
 
"Mathematics is the most abstract of all the sciences. For it makes no external observations, nor asserts anything as a real fact. When the mathematician deals with facts, they become for him mere ‘hypotheses’; for with their truth he refuses to concern himself. The whole science of mathematics is a science of hypotheses; so that nothing could be more completely abstracted from concrete reality." (Charles S Peirce, "The Regenerated Logic", The Monist Vol. 7 (1), 1896)
 
"The union of the mathematician with the poet, fervor with measure, passion with correctness, this surely is the ideal." (William James, "Clifford's Lectures and Essays", 1897) 

"Mathematicians will do well to observe that a reasonable acquaintance with theoretical physics at its present stage of development, to mention only such broad subjects as electricity, elastics, hydrodynamics, etc., is as much as most of us can keep permanently assimilated. It should also be remembered that the step from the formal elegance of theory to the brute arithmetic of the special case is always humiliating, and that this labor usually falls to the lot of the physicist." (Carl Barus, "The Mathematical Theory of the Top", 1898)
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

🪸On Systems Thinking: On Function (2010-)

"All forms of complex causation, and especially nonlinear transformations, admittedly stack the deck against prediction. Linear describ...