On Idealization: Truth

"There is a logic of language and a logic of mathematics. The former is supple and lifelike, it follows our experience. The latter is abstract and rigid, more ideal. The latter is perfectly necessary, perfectly reliable: the former is only sometimes reliable and hardly ever systematic. But the logic of mathematics achieves necessity at the expense of living truth, it is less real than the other, although more certain. It achieves certainty by a flight from the concrete into abstraction." (Thomas Merton, "The Secular Journal of Thomas Merton", 1959)

"The idea of approximation to the truth is, in my view, one of the most important ideas in the theory of science. [...] The idea of approximation to the truth - like the idea of truth as are gulative principle - presupposes a realistic view of the world. It does not presuppose that reality is as our scientific theories describe it; but it does presuppose that there is a reality and that we and our theories - which are ideas we have ourselves created and are therefore always idealizations - can draw closer and closer to an adequate description of reality, if we employ the four-stage method of trial and error." (Karl R Popper, "The Logic and Evolution of Scientific Theory", [in "All Life is Problem Solving", 1999] 1972)

"The introduction and gradual acceptance of concepts that have no immediate counterparts in the real world certainly forced the recognition that mathematics is a human, somewhat arbitrary creation, rather than an idealization of the realities in nature, derived solely from nature. But accompanying this recognition and indeed propelling its acceptance was a more profound discovery - mathematics is not a body of truths about nature." (Morris Kline, "Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times" Vol. III, 1972)

"The assumption of rationality has a favored position in economics. It is accorded all the methodological privileges of a self-evident truth, a reasonable idealization, a tautology, and a null hypothesis. Each of these interpretations either puts the hypothesis of rational action beyond question or places the burden of proof squarely on any alternative analysis of belief and choice. The advantage of the rational model is compounded because no other theory of judgment and decision can ever match it in scope, power, and simplicity." (Amos Tversky & Daniel Kahneman, "Rational Choice and the Framing of Decisions", The Journal of Business Vol. 59 (4), 1986)

"The reason why a 'crude', experimental approach is not adequate for determining mathematical truth lies in the nature of what mathematics is and is intended to be. Though its roots lie in the physical world, mathematics is a precise and idealized discipline. The 'points', 'lines', 'planes', and other ideal constructs of mathematics have no exact counterpart in reality. What the mathematician does is to take a totally abstract, idealized view of the world, and reason with his abstractions in an entirely precise and rigorous fashion." (Keith Devlin, "Mathematics: The New Golden Age", 1998)