On Conjecture (2000-2019)

"It is sometimes said that mathematics is not an experimental subject. This is not true! Mathematicians often use the evidence of lots of examples to help form a conjecture, and this is an experimental approach. Having formed a conjecture about what might be true, the next task is to try to prove it." (George M Phillips, "Mathematics Is Not a Spectator Sport", 2000)

"A felicitous but unproved conjecture may be of much more consequence for mathematics than the proof of many a respectable theorem." (Atle Selberg, 2001)

"Given a conjecture, the best thing is to prove it. The second best thing is to disprove it. The third best thing is to prove that it is not possible to disprove it, since it will tell you not to waste your time trying to disprove it." (Saharon Shelah, [Rutgers University Colloquium] 2001)

"Mathematicians often get bored by a problem after they have fully understood it and have given proofs of their conjectures. Sometimes they even forget the precise details of what they have done after the lapse of years, having refocused their interest in another area. The common notion of the mathematician contemplating timeless truths, thinking over the same proof again and again - Euclid looking on beauty bare - is rarely true in any static sense." (Avner Ash & Robert Gross, "Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the hidden patterns of numbers", 2006)

"Still, in the end, we find ourselves drawn to the beauty of the patterns themselves, and the amazing fact that we humans are smart enough to prove even a feeble fraction of all possible theorems about them. Often, greater than the contemplation of this beauty for the active mathematician is the excitement of the chase. Trying to discover first what patterns actually do or do not occur, then finding the correct statement of a conjecture, and finally proving it - these things are exhilarating when accomplished successfully. Like all risk-takers, mathematicians labor months or years for these moments of success." (Avner Ash & Robert Gross, "Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the hidden patterns of numbers", 2006)

"The word conjecture means 'guess'. The way it is used in mathematics is 'educated guess'." (Avner Ash & Robert Gross, "Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the hidden patterns of numbers", 2006)

"Mathematics is the art of explanation. If you deny students the opportunity to engage in this activity - to pose their own problems, to make their own conjectures and discoveries, to be wrong, to be creatively frustrated, to have an inspiration, and to cobble together their own explanations and proofs - you deny them mathematics itself." (Paul Lockhart, "A Mathematician's Lament", 2009)

"Mathematics is the music of reason. To do mathematics is to engage in an act of discovery and conjecture, intuition and inspiration; to be in a state of confusion - not because it makes no sense to you, but because you gave it sense and you still don't understand what your creation is up to; to have a break-through idea; to be frustrated as an artist; to be awed and overwhelmed by an almost painful beauty; to be alive, damn it." (Paul Lockhart, "A Mathematician's Lament", 2009)

"The reasoning of the mathematician and that of the scientist are similar to a point. Both make conjectures often prompted by particular observations. Both advance tentative generalizations and look for supporting evidence of their validity. Both consider specific implications of their generalizations and put those implications to the test. Both attempt to understand their generalizations in the sense of finding explanations for them in terms of concepts with which they are already familiar. Both notice fragmentary regularities and - through a process that may include false starts and blind alleys - attempt to put the scattered details together into what appears to be a meaningful whole. At some point, however, the mathematician’s quest and that of the scientist diverge. For scientists, observation is the highest authority, whereas what mathematicians seek ultimately for their conjectures is deductive proof." (Raymond S Nickerson, "Mathematical Reasoning: Patterns, Problems, Conjectures and Proofs", 2009)

"Truth in mathematics is totally dependent on pure thought, with no component of data to be added. This is unique. Associated with truth in mathematics is an absolute certainty in its validity. Why does this matter, and why does it go beyond a cultural oddity of our profession? The answer is that mathematics is deeply embedded in the reasoning used within many branches of knowledge. That reasoning often involves conjectures, assumptions, intuition. But whatever aspect has been reduced to mathematics has an absolute validity. As in other subjects search for truth, the mathematical components embedded in their search are like the boulders in the stream, providing a solid footing on which to cross from one side to the other." (James Glimm, "Reflections and Prospectives", 2009)

"Essentially, engaging in the practice of mathematics means that you are playing around, making observations and discoveries, constructing examples (as well as counterexamples), formulating conjectures, and then - the hard part - 'proving them'." (Paul Lockhart, "Measurement", 2012)

"There are thousands of apparent mathematical truths out there that we humans have discovered and believe to be true but have so far been unable to prove. They are called conjectures. A conjecture is simply a statement about mathematical reality that you believe to be true [..]" (Paul Lockhart, "Measurement", 2012)