Qualitative vs Quantitative IV: Trivia

"To us […] the only acceptable point of view appears to be the one that recognizes both sides of reality - the quantitative and the qualitative, the physical and the psychical - as compatible with each other, and can embrace them simultaneously […] It would be most satisfactory of all if physis and psyche (i.e., matter and mind) could be seen as complementary aspects of the same reality." (Wolfgang Pauli', "The Influence of Archetypal Ideas on the Scientific Theories of Kepler", [Lecture at the Psychological Club of Zurich], 1948)

"As long as economic theory still works on a purely qualitative basis without attempting to measure the numerical importance of the various factors, practically any 'conclusion' can be drawn and defended." (Ragnar Frisch, "From Utopian Theory to Practical Applications", [Nobel lecture] 1970)

"Quantify. If whatever it is you’re explaining has some measure, some numerical quantity attached to it, you’ll be much better able to discriminate among competing hypotheses. What is vague and qualitative is open to many explanations." (Carl Sagan, "The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark", 1995)

"Reductionism argues that from scientific theories which explain phenomena on one level, explanations for a higher level can be deduced. Reality and our experience can be reduced to a number of indivisible basic elements. Also qualitative properties are possible to reduce to quantitative ones." (Lars Skyttner, "General Systems Theory: Ideas and Applications", 2001)

"As every bookie knows instinctively, a number such as reliability - a qualitative rather than a quantitative measure - is needed to make the valuation of information practically useful." (Hans Christian von Baeyer, "Information, The New Language of Science", 2003)

"Our culture, obsessed with numbers, has given us the idea that what we can measure is more important than what we can't measure. Think about that for a minute. It means that we make quantity more important than quality." (Donella Meadows, "Thinking in Systems: A Primer", 2008)

"So everyone has and uses mental representations. What sets expert performers apart from everyone else is the quality and quantity of their mental representations. Through years of practice, they develop highly complex and sophisticated representations of the various situations they are likely to encounter in their fields - such as the vast number of arrangements of chess pieces that can appear during games. These representations allow them to make faster, more accurate decisions and respond more quickly and effectively in a given situation. This, more than anything else, explains the difference in performance between novices and experts." (Anders Ericsson & Robert Pool," "Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise" , 2016)

"It’d be nice to fondly imagine that high-quality statistics simply appear in a spreadsheet somewhere, divine providence from the numerical heavens. Yet any dataset begins with somebody deciding to collect the numbers. What numbers are and aren’t collected, what is and isn’t measured, and who is included or excluded are the result of all-too-human assumptions, preconceptions, and oversights." (Tim Harford, "The Data Detective: Ten easy rules to make sense of statistics", 2020)

"For although it is certainly true that quantitative measurements are of great importance, it is a grave error to suppose that the whole of experimental physics can be brought under this heading. We can start measuring only when we know what to measure: qualitative observation has to precede quantitative measurement, and by making experimental arrangements for quantitative measurements we may even eliminate the possibility of new phenomena appearing." (Heinrich B G Casimir)

Qualitative vs Quantitative III: Complex Systems

"It is not enough to know the critical stress, that is, the quantitative breaking point of a complex design; one should also know as much as possible of the qualitative geometry of its failure modes, because what will happen beyond the critical stress level can be very different from one case to the next, depending on just which path the buckling takes. And here catastrophe theory, joined with bifurcation theory, can be very helpful by indicating how new failure modes appear." (Alexander Woodcock & Monte Davis, "Catastrophe Theory", 1978)

"Yet wherever the cracks appear, they show a tendency to extend towards each other, to form characteristic networks, to form specific types of junctions. The location, the magnitude, and the timing of the cracks (their quantitative aspects) are beyond calculation, but their patterns of growth and the topology of their joining (the qualitative aspects) recur again and again." (Alexander Woodcock & Monte Davis, "Catastrophe Theory", 1978)

"In the long run, qualitative changes always outweigh quantitative ones. Quantitative predictions of economic and social trends are made obsolete by qualitative changes in the rules of the game. Quantitative predictions of technological progress are made obsolete by unpredictable new inventions. I am interested in the long run, the remote future, where quantitative predictions are meaningless. The only certainty in that remote future is that radically new things will be happening." (Freeman J Dyson, "Disturbing the Universe", 1979)

"The pinball machine is one of those rare dynamical systems whose chaotic nature we can deduce by pure qualitative reasoning, with fair confidence that we have not wandered astray. Nevertheless, the angles in the paths of the balls that are introduced whenever a ball strikes a pin and rebounds […] render the system some what inconvenient for detailed quantitative study." (Edward N Lorenz, "The Essence of Chaos", 1993)

"[…] the meaning of the word 'solve' has undergone a series of major changes. First that word meant 'find a formula'. Then its meaning changed to 'find approximate numbers'. Finally, it has in effect become 'tell me what the solutions look like'. In place of quantitative answers, we seek qualitative ones." (Ian Stewart, "Nature's Numbers: The unreal reality of mathematics", 1995)

"The concept of bifurcation, present in the context of non-linear dynamic systems and theory of chaos, refers to the transition between two dynamic modalities qualitatively distinct; both of them are exhibited by the same dynamic system, and the transition (bifurcation) is promoted by the change in value of a relevant numeric parameter of such system. Such parameter is named 'bifurcation parameter', and in highly non-linear dynamic systems, its change can produce a large number of bifurcations between distinct dynamic modalities, with self-similarity and fractal structure. In many of these systems, we have a cascade of numberless bifurcations, culminating with the production of chaotic dynamics." (Emilio Del-Moral-Hernandez, "Chaotic Neural Networks", Encyclopedia of Artificial Intelligence, 2009)

"A commonly accepted principle of systems dynamics is that a quantitative change, beyond a critical point, results in a qualitative change. Accordingly, a difference in degree may become a difference in kind. This doesn't mean that an increased quantity of a given variable will bring a qualitative change in the variable itself. However, when the state of a system depends on a set of variables, a quantitative change in one variable beyond the inflection point will result in a change of phase in the state of the system. This change is a qualitative one, representing a whole new set of relationships among the variables involved." (Jamshid Gharajedaghi, "Systems Thinking: Managing Chaos and Complexity A Platform for Designing Business Architecture" 3rd Ed., 2011)

"Whether information comes in a quantitative or qualitative flavor is not as important as how you use it. [...] The key to making a good forecast […] is not in limiting yourself to quantitative information. Rather, it’s having a good process for weighing the information appropriately. […] collect as much information as possible, but then be as rigorous and disciplined as possible when analyzing it. [...] Many times, in fact, it is possible to translate qualitative information into quantitative information." (Nate Silver, "The Signal and the Noise: Why So Many Predictions Fail-but Some Don't", 2012)

Qualitative vs Quantitative II: Models

"A model is a qualitative or quantitative representation of a process or endeavor that shows the effects of those factors which are significant for the purposes being considered. A model may be pictorial, descriptive, qualitative, or generally approximate in nature; or it may be mathematical and quantitative in nature and reasonably precise. It is important that effective means for modeling be understood such as analog, stochastic, procedural, scheduling, flow chart, schematic, and block diagrams." (Harold Chestnut, "Systems Engineering Tools", 1965)

"As is used in connection with systems engineering, a model is a qualitative or quantitative representation of a process or endeavor that shows the effects of those factors which are significant for the purposes being considered. Modeling is the process of making a model. Although the model may not represent the actual phenomenon in all respects, it does describe the essential inputs, outputs, and internal characteristics, as well as provide an indication of environmental conditions similar to those of actual equipment." (Harold Chestnut, "Systems Engineering Tools", 1965)

"Modeling, in a general sense, refers to the establishment of a description of a system (a plant, a process, etc.) in mathematical terms, which characterizes the input-output behavior of the underlying system. To describe a physical system […] we have to use a mathematical formula or equation that can represent the system both qualitatively and quantitatively. Such a formulation is a mathematical representation, called a mathematical model, of the physical system." (Guanrong Chen & Trung Tat Pham, "Introduction to Fuzzy Sets, Fuzzy Logic, and Fuzzy Control Systems", 2001)

"Reductionism argues that from scientific theories which explain phenomena on one level, explanations for a higher level can be deduced. Reality and our experience can be reduced to a number of indivisible basic elements. Also qualitative properties are possible to reduce to quantitative ones." (Lars Skyttner, "General Systems Theory: Ideas and Applications", 2001) 

"In order to understand how mathematics is applied to understanding of the real world it is convenient to subdivide it into the following three modes of functioning: model, theory, metaphor. A mathematical model describes a certain range of phenomena qualitatively or quantitatively. […] A (mathematical) metaphor, when it aspires to be a cognitive tool, postulates that some complex range of phenomena might be compared to a mathematical construction." (Yuri I Manin," Mathematics as Metaphor: Selected Essays of Yuri I. Manin" , 2007)

Qualitative vs Quantitative I: Mathematics

"But it is a third geometry from which quantity is completely excluded and which is purely qualitative; this is analysis situs. In this discipline, two figures are equivalent whenever one can pass from one to the other by a continuous deformation; whatever else the law of this deformation may be, it must be continuous. Thus, a circle is equivalent to an ellipse or even to an arbitrary closed curve, but it is not equivalent to a straight-line segment since this segment is not closed. A sphere is equivalent to any convex surface; it is not equivalent to a torus since there is a hole in a torus and in a sphere there is not. Imagine an arbitrary design and a copy of this same design executed by an unskilled draftsman; the properties are altered, the straight lines drawn by an inexperienced hand have suffered unfortunate deviations and contain awkward bends. From the point of view of metric geometry, and even of projective geometry, the two figures are not equivalent; on the contrary, from the point of view of analysis situs, they are." (Henri Poincaré, "Dernières pensées", 1913)

"Mathematics, or the science of magnitudes, is that system which studies the quantitative relations between things; logic, or the science of concepts, is that system which studies the qualitative (categorical) relations between things." (Peter D Ouspensky, "Tertium Organum: The Third Canon of Thought; a Key to the Enigmas of the World", 1922)

"Statistics is the fundamental and most important part of inductive logic. It is both an art and a science, and it deals with the collection, the tabulation, the analysis and interpretation of quantitative and qualitative measurements. It is concerned with the classifying and determining of actual attributes as well as the making of estimates and the testing of various hypotheses by which probable, or expected, values are obtained. It is one of the means of carrying on scientific research in order to ascertain the laws of behavior of things - be they animate or inanimate. Statistics is the technique of the Scientific Method." (Bruce D Greenschields & Frank M Weida, "Statistics with Applications to Highway Traffic Analyses", 1952)

"Numbers have neither substance, nor meaning, nor qualities. They are nothing but marks, and all that is in them we have put into them by the simple rule of straight succession." (Hermann Weyl, "Mathematics and the Laws of Nature", 1959)

"Statistics provides a quantitative example of the scientific process usually described qualitatively by saying that scientists observe nature, study the measurements, postulate models to predict new measurements, and validate the model by the success of prediction." (Marshall J Walker, "The Nature of Scientific Thought", 1963)

"A common objection to the use of mathematics in the social sciences is that the information available may only be qualitative, not quantitative. There are, however, several branches of mathematics that deal effectively with qualitative information. A very good example is graph theory." (John G Kemeny, "The Social Sciences Call on Mathematics", The Mathematical Sciences: A Collection of Essays, 1969)

"Because of its foundation in topology, catastrophe theory is qualitative, not quantitative. Just as geometry treated the properties of a triangle without regard to its size, so topology deals with properties that have no magnitude, for example, the property of a given point being inside or outside a closed curve or surface. This property is what topologists call 'invariant' -it does not change even when the curve is distorted. A topologist may work with seven-dimensional space, but he does not and cannot measure (in the ordinary sense) along any of those dimensions. The ability to classify and manipulate all types of form is achieved only by giving up concepts such as size, distance, and rate. So while catastrophe theory is well suited to describe and even to predict the shape of processes, its descriptions and predictions are not quantitative like those of theories built upon calculus. Instead, they are rather like maps without a scale: they tell us that there are mountains to the left, a river to the right, and a cliff somewhere ahead, but not how far away each is, or how large." (Alexander Woodcock & Monte Davis, "Catastrophe Theory", 1978)

"An essential difference between continuity and differentiability is whether numbers are involved or not. The concept of continuity is characterized by the qualitative property that nearby objects are mapped to nearby objects. However, the concept of differentiation is obtained by using the ratio of infinitesimal increments. Therefore, we see that differentiability essentially involves numbers." (Kenji Ueno & Toshikazu Sunada, "A Mathematical Gift, III: The Interplay Between Topology, Functions, Geometry, and Algebra", Mathematical World Vol. 23, 1996)

"There is a certain ambiguity in the concept of angle, for it describes both the qualitative idea of 'separation' between two intersecting lines, and the numerical value of this separation-the measure of the angle. (Note that this is not so with the analogous 'separation' between two points, where the phrases line segment and length make the distinction clear.) Fortunately we need not worry about this ambiguity, for trigonometry is concerned only with the quantitative aspects of line segments and angles." (Eli Maor, "Trigonometric Delights", 1998)

"Topology allows the possibility of making qualitative predictions when quantitative ones are impossible." (Timothy Gowers, "The Princeton Companion to Mathematics", 2008)